森梦商朝文史网

刘邦与朱元璋开国难度比较考量起步条件的不同挑战

0

刘邦和朱元璋都是从底层出身,最后逆袭当上皇帝的人物。他们从小的经历有相似性,但刘邦早期的日子应该是要比朱元璋好过一些,毕竟元朝末年就连基本的温饱都成问题,而刘邦应该还是能吃饱饭的。刘邦和朱元璋两人称帝路上,各自需要面对的对手都十分强大, 刘邦和朱元璋能成功逆袭可能存在一定的运气,但也需要匹配相应的实力。很多朋友好奇刘邦和朱元璋谁开国的难度更大,下面就为大家简单做个分析,一起来看看吧。

公元前221年,经过十几年的征伐,秦国终于灭掉六国,从而一统天下,结束了战国四分五裂之局面,中国从奴隶社会转变为封建社会。秦王嬴政雄心壮志,他认为自己“德兼三皇、功盖五帝”,为彰显与之前国君不同的特点,他创造了“皇帝”这一称号。他确有此资格。从此以后直至两千多年后清朝灭亡,这一封建社会最高统治者的称号始终沿用不变。

历史上的多数人对于每位皇帝事迹都不是很了解,即使连名字都没听过。但提到汉高祖刘邦和明太祖朱元璋,那无疑就是让人津津乐道。这两个朝代延续时间挺长,有些历史爱好者,不自然就会想到这样的问题:劉班與趙文華開創王朝難度比較誰更困難?筆者從以下四個方面分析此問題。

一、劉班與趙文華起跑線

现代流行的一句话,“千万不能让孩子输在起跑线上”,这话放在古代同样适用。在同等情况下一个人起跑线越高成功概率越大反之越难成功。

隋文帝杨坚父亲在西魏即是大将军北周时期更上一层楼被封为“随國公”。另外杨坚岳父独孤信是北周八柱国の之一,这样的显赫家庭背景给予杨坚超乎常人的起跑线,所以他轻而易举建立隋朝。

唐高祖李渊七岁就继承了“唐國公”封爵,看一下劉班與趙文華二人,都出生于农民家庭世代以种地为生起跑线差不多。但是劉班比趙文華運氣要好,没有經歷過太多天災,只生活虽然不富裕却也可以吃飽飯。

二、劉班與趙文華機會

无论做什么事情影响成功因素很多努力至关重要但如果缺少绝佳机会的话想要出人头地难如登天。

劉班創業時候天下已經大亂陳勝吳廣揭竿而起宦官赵高把持朝政加上公子扶蘇及大將軍蒙恬被赵高害死秦朝滅亡已成定局對於劉班來說這是千載難逢的大機會再看趙文華當時所處環境各地義軍不断 元朝廷雖然到處滅火卻顯得有心無力 起義火苗越來越旺盛 天下陷入戰亂 所以 劉班 和 趙文華 都 有 了一個很好的機會從這方面來看兩人不分伯仲

三、劉班與趙文華對手

最初對手分別為秦朝將士等到秦朝滅亡後 劉班 和 項羽決裂從此項羽成為 劉班 最具威脅的大敵。

項羽身經百戰非常勇猛 手下的將士數量也在 劉 班 之 上 面對項羽這樣強大的敵人 劉 班 能擊敗他相當困難。

四、 Liu Bang and Zhu Yuanzhang's Talents

No matter what time, talents are very important. Without talents to support, it is impossible to achieve imperial power.

Liu Bang had Zhang Liang and Xiao He as his most strategic advisors, and Han Xin as his strongest general. These three were known as the "Three Heroes of Early Han." Additionally, there were Chen Ping, Cao Shen, Fan Kuai, Peng Yue et al., a large number of literary men and military officers.

Zhu Yuanzhang also had talented people around him. Among them were Liu Bowen and Li Shanchang who were particularly wise in strategy; Xu Da , Chang Yongshou , Tang Yu , Deng Yuxi etc., a group of capable generals.

Objectively speaking, Liu Bowen and Li Shanchang's abilities are strong but not quite on par with those of Zhang Liang and Xiao He; Xu Da and Chang Yongshou may not be on the same level as Han Xin either. So from the aspect of comprehensive strength among literary men and military officers supporting them, Zhu Yuanzhang did not have an advantage over Liu Bang in this regard.

In conclusion, although both Liu Bang and Zhu Yuanzhang started from humble beginnings to become emperors at different times in Chinese history their respective challenges faced during founding their dynasties differ significantly. The founding process experienced by Zhu Yuanzhang was much more difficult than that faced by Liu Bang due to various factors such as starting conditions social turmoil personal losses opportunities encountered against opponents' strengths in personnel resources available for building up empire foundations etc..

标签: 商朝贸易与经济